Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD23 → Feedback comment stats → ben

ben

Feedback comments for LD23

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	ben's comment
Apr 23 17:18:00		Planet 161	Great job! I played until the level theme switch.
Apr 23 21:48:00	4h 30m	The Wizard Delven	It was apparent you put alot of thought and effort into this, though i just had no inclination to want to explore and figure any of it out. It would've really helped if your read-me had been decently formatted so i could read it more easily.
Apr 23 21:59:00	11m 00s	Ancestor's Sword	Your game definitely stood out to me during the competition and i'm glad developement went well for you. The art is great and the theme/narrative are cool. The scrolling text for speech was a bit annoying, maybe if you could only speak to them once, or once in a while it would've been better. I liked the growing mechanic, was very interesting way to further your main mechanic. The main gravity mechanic however i didn't enjoy. It just made the whole platforming element shitty for me, i hated trying to do jumps and stuff while upside down. Overall had a good time! : ]
Apr 23 22:02:00	3m 00s	Burning Platform	Wish i could play, respect though for making a game only available on the least accessible platform :]
Apr 23 22:08:00	6m 00s	Lost Lapootah	That was sooo good! I loved every part of it, except the movement getting caught on corners and stuff but other than that you rock and i had a fun time.
Apr 23 22:15:00	7m 00s	CAPSULE [web]	As an exploration you obviously succeeded what you were trying. As an interactive piece of media it failed pretty bad for me. I didn't understand what i could influence or why i would want to or what affect my actions were having. If you started with a simpler situation with a smaller amount of things to influence and some more direction for the player i think it would've been more succesful.
Apr 23 22:25:00	10m 00s	The Sheep Are Sinking	Seemed kinda broken for me, the sheep wouldn't move and i didn't see any other creatures. Really cool concept though i'd love to see it developed further.
Apr 23 22:30:00	5m 00s	Large Hadron Collider: Ludum Dare Edition	Sweet : ] Love the name and idea. Though it really needed some tight speedy movement i think, it felt really sluggish and kind of a pain to maneuver around.
Apr 23 22:38:00	8m 00s	Interstellar Planet-Ship Adventures: The Search for... $@#% Aliens!!!!!!	Sorry i really didn't want to work through the learning curve at the start but it definitely looks cool and i applaud your ambition.
Apr 23 22:41:00	3m 00s	Green Invasion	Cool little game! The controls are unique, though they felt kinda bad for me, probably because i have a very high sensitivity. Graphics were great.
Apr 23 22:43:00	2m 00s	MyLittleWorld	Couldn't be bothered to figure out silverlight.
Apr 23 22:46:00	3m 00s	TinyFish	Cute little game : } The game itself wasn't a whole lot of fun but i loved the graphics and feel of it. Very unique take on the comp theme as well.
Apr 23 22:49:00	3m 00s	The Tower of the Four Winds	Nice work. Look forward to seeing what do next comp. You might want to consider using a library of some sort so you can focus more on actual gameplay and design.
Apr 23 22:55:00	6m 00s	Rockland	Hilarious, i laughed at the "all birds have coins!!!"
Apr 23 23:04:00	9m 00s	Skully's Microscopic World	Was interesting and i played for awhile but eventually stopped since i didn't seem to have any goal or way to win. I really liked the audio interjections and i think the game could've used a bunch more
Apr 23 23:13:00	9m 00s	Tiny Quest	Great graphics, feeling and theme are perfect. Mechanics though were quite bad.
Apr 23 23:19:00	6m 00s	Save the tiny world!	Damn those pigz! Cute game : ]
Apr 23 23:24:00	5m 00s	When Worlds Collide	Nice simple gameplay, executed excellently! Some sound would really do wonders for this game i think.
Apr 23 23:34:00	10m 00s	Expand Explore Expatiate	Exploring some really cool ideas. I'd love to see them developed further, maybe in combination with some other mechanic to keep me more engaged, narrative, combat, something like that.
Apr 23 23:42:00	8m 00s	A Super Mario Summary	Rad
Apr 23 23:44:00	2m 00s	Revolves	Cool, some more levels would've been great.
Apr 23 23:48:00	4m 00s	Tiny World Defense Force	Was interesting for sure :]
Apr 24 00:04:00	16m 00s	Hoperay	Nice work, i didnt have alot of fun but that's just because i dislike the genre you chose. Very well executed!
Apr 24 00:07:00	3m 00s	Scorched Earth	All alone here :_{
Apr 24 00:12:00	5m 00s	Ra Ra	Seems like alot of fun, i'll have to come back to it when i've got someone to play with.
Apr 24 13:42:00	13h 30m	Scape	Awesome game! had lots of fun, played till the end : D
Apr 24 13:51:00	9m 00s	Tiny Galaxy	Cool game, i would've played longer if you had included some easier challenges at the start that i could get my feet wet with. It seemed like everywhere i went it was telling "You can't do that yet you need THIS" and it was quite frustrating.
Apr 25 20:05:00	30h 14m	Phi	Was an interesting experience. It kept me engaged till the end, though when i saw the diagram it was immediately obvious what the code was, so i was a bit dissapointed i had to do all the work of collecting information without really feeling like i figured anything difficult out. The movement speed was kinda slow started to get tedious walking around and the sound design was very irritation. Nice work! : ]
Apr 25 20:11:00	6m 00s	Core Buster	Cool tech, i definitely had some fun once i got the second weapon. Probably would've played longer if you'd had some more interesting gameplay, like real missions of some sorts, enemies maybe. Great job!
Apr 25 20:18:00	7m 00s	Link	Neat game! I stopped playing because i'm too impatient to sit through that awfully slow narrative stuff, but i had fun nonetheless
Apr 25 20:24:00	6m 00s	SUPER SPACE MINER	Neat game, well executed. Except for the music not working.