Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD34 → Feedback comment stats → brainstorm
Feedback comments for LD34
brainstorm's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | brainstorm's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 14 19:46:00 | Flappy blue rabbit | Innovation 3/5: Platformer and Flappy Birds fusion. At least is not a Flappy Birds exact clone. <br/> <br/>Fun 1/5: Boring because of lack of difficult. <br/> <br/>Theme 2/5: Used in an unoriginal way. <br/> <br/>Graphics 4/5: Not bad artistic style. <br/> <br/>Audio n/a: Don't audio, maybe because lack of time. <br/> <br/>Humor 4/5: Funny enemies. <br/> <br/>Mood 3/5: A music would be great but the graphics gave to it an interesting abstract atmosphere (not sure if intended). <br/> <br/>Overall 3/5: Lack of time damaged a lot this game. But it's abstract atmosphere is quite good. Try to spend more time in your next entry! :) | |
| Dec 14 21:03:00 | 1h 17m | Overgrow | Innovation 2/5: Not really innovative gameplay. Nice touch the detail of the petals as health. <br/> <br/>Fun 2/5: Funny for 3 or 4 attempts. <br/> <br/>Theme 3/5: Grow doesn't affect directly to the gameplay, also, controls are a reference to the two buttons theme? <br/> <br/>Graphics 5/5: Good combination of pixel art with the meme-faced flower :). Good enough for a 72 hours game. <br/> <br/>Audio 3/5: Two sfx. At least it have something. <br/> <br/>Humor 5/5: Loved the flower faces and absurd story. <br/> <br/>Mood 4/5: Some music would be great, but graphics make a funny atmosphere. <br/> <br/>Overall 3/5: Not bad, but needs improvements. Good for being your first game jam! |
| Dec 14 21:24:00 | 21m 00s | Feed the Queen | Innovation 3/5: Not reslly innovative mechanics, but I liked that you die if you don't take some flowers. <br/> <br/>Fun 2/5: Near impossible because of the controls and the tongue animation. <br/> <br/>Theme 5/5: Growing weight is an original theme. I'll forgot the typic use of the two buttons one ;) <br/> <br/>Graphics 4/5: A bit blurry sprites, liked the queen sprite. <br/> <br/>Audio 3/5: Simple soundtrack and a few sound effects. Liked a lot the death sound. <br/> <br/>Humor 5/5: Hilarious game, liked the hand-written letter at the start and queen canibalism habits. NO ENOUGH FOOD, I'LL EAT YOU! <br/> <br/>Mood 1/5: Not really worked that part. Not necessary though. <br/> <br/>Overall 3/5: A bit rushed game. Humor parts are the best of the game. |
| Dec 15 17:37:00 | 20h 13m | Snekklr | Innovation 5/5: Really innovative game! <br/> <br/>Fun 4/5: It's really fun oto it your tail, your body and the rest of the snake's sgements. The Ai kills himself though. But don't worry, make a good AI ith aa lack of time is difficult :) <br/> <br/>Theme 3/5: Not really well used. But used. <br/> <br/>Graphics 4/5: Really consistent primitives. <br/> <br/>Humor 4/5: As I said, ating your tail is funny. <br/> <br/>Mood n/a: Not sure if intended. <br/> <br/>Overall 4/5: That's the Ultimate Suicide Snake Simulator 2K16! |
| Dec 15 17:58:00 | 21m 00s | 1 Button Wizard X2 | Innovation 5/5: Really innovative game! <br/> <br/>Fun 4/5: It's repetitive after a while, but trying different spells is funny. <br/> <br/>Theme 5/5: Great use of theme! <br/> <br/>Graphics 2/5: Rushed MS Paint graphics. At least have charm :). <br/> <br/>Humor 4/5: Funny enemies. <br/> <br/>Mood 3/5: The backgrounds and characters give to it a fantastical environment mood. <br/> <br/>Overall 5/5: Great entry, improve graphics and change a bit the controls (I would suggest one button for green circles and anoher fo red ones). It have a lot of potential. |
| Dec 15 18:11:00 | 13m 00s | Holiday Rejects | Really well done game! <br/> <br/>I voted 5/5 on every category except two 4/5 in Fun and Theme. <br/> <br/>Great game, maybe it starts getting difficult too late, but I can't find more defects. :) |
| Dec 15 18:21:00 | 10m 00s | Judge or jump ! | I found it a bit difficult to understant, but it's a fun game. The use of the Theme, the tense mood and the sense of humor are the best of the game, but I don't really understanded the criteria used to calificate someone as 'good' or 'bad'. |
| Dec 15 18:27:00 | 6m 00s | Flower Power | Great game! I love everything in it except that if you are on a corner you could be easily killed by an obstacle without having time to react. |
| Dec 15 18:33:00 | 6m 00s | Vrach's Lab | Great game, but I think I saw that kind of growing/shrink runner kind of game. Graphics are awesome too. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 15 18:39:00 | 6m 00s | Jay in Love Garden | Really difficult. Apart of that good use of the theme. Alos, not bad graphic and somewhat innovative. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 15 18:57:00 | 18m 00s | Squirrel Forest | I haven't really understanded it at all. Maybe because I haven't a mouse (I use a laptop) and I can't scroll nothing. You maybe should have added keyboard controls. That's a shame because I liked the charming graphics and your choice of incompeetech music. For next Jam, make a more accesible-controls for all game and you could have a good position. :) <br/> <br/>2/5 |
| Dec 15 19:07:00 | 10m 00s | Control Two Buttons | Hahaha, really original idea. I loved the story, but the paper clip maybe is too strong. Song is a bit too repetitive. Good game overall. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 15 19:19:00 | 12m 00s | Go Fish | Great choice of theme. Too easy game, but this plus the music makes it really relaxing. So, great mood, good graphics, great use of the theme, and a bit boring mechanic. :) <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 15 19:37:00 | 18m 00s | Super Meet Ball | Great game! I only had problems with the controls because they're a bit difficult to learn. Keep up the good work! <br/> <br/>5/5 |
| Dec 15 19:46:00 | 9m 00s | Gardening Rabbit | Really feels as a Game & Watch. Everything in the game is nice, except that it's a bit repetitive after a while. Great game. Also, why have took down the innovation category? :) <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 17 19:09:00 | 47h 23m | A Shot in the Dark | Awesome game! I loved it. Good use of the theme and amazing mood. <br/> <br/>5/5 |
| Dec 17 19:21:00 | 12m 00s | Lawnmower Puzzle | Not bad mechanics, but they're too complicated, at least for my taste. Also there's an annoying scratch sounding. But very innovative and good use of the theme. So you had a great idea and executed it bad. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 17 20:04:00 | 43m 00s | Eva Ness goes to Hell | Hey, don't be so harsh with yourself. It's a great game for a Compo. And it would be also for a Jam. I'd seen a lot of worse games. It lacks a bit in graphics and in sounds, and the final boss is maybe too easier. But otherwise that's a really solid entry. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 17 20:37:00 | 33m 00s | Sort the Court! | Great game! It have a lot of hilarious dialogues, and I love that actions will make hings change. Also, random characters like the wizard were a nice addition. A really solid entry. <br/> <br/>5/5 |
| Dec 18 12:36:00 | 15h 59m | Proud Sprout | Great mood! Controls are OK. Also, not sure if that's a bug, but in last level (the wall-jumping one) there's a bug. You can enter into the ground and climb it. Also great mood. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 18 12:41:00 | 5m 00s | It's Cupid, Stupid | Nice pixel art and really innovative. Also, great humor sense. Too bad it haven't sounds. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 18 15:43:00 | 3h 02m | The Rap Game | Neat graphics and audio, but it's too hard to win and there isn't usage of theme. Overall a great and original game. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 18 15:55:00 | 12m 00s | SEED | Though it isn't really innovative, the surprising use of the grow theme, the duration and the cute graphics makes this a great game. <br/> <br/>5/10 |
| Dec 18 16:00:00 | 5m 00s | Inner Circle | I don't know how, but this is quite addictive! Really interesting concept, but as someone said in the comments, it needs a rotate animation. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 20 10:44:00 | 42h 44m | Grow Your Hoard! | Great entry! It have a lot of charm, and I loved the pixel art! It's also really innovative and funny! <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 20 11:59:00 | 1h 15m | No One Can Hear You Honk in Space | I can see a great work with humor and graphics here. Sadly, the gameplay is sometimes a bit frustrating because of permadeath. Keep up the good work! <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 20 18:53:00 | 6h 54m | Growing Weed | LOL, that was hilarious, but it gets boring very fast because it's really difficult to obtain money. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 20 18:59:00 | 6m 00s | Great Nation | Great use of the theme, seen it in other entries!Good sense of humor lack of questions makes it a bit repetitive though. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 20 19:07:00 | 8m 00s | Growcoon | It have some charm, but controls felt a bit irresponsive (I haven't managed to buy nothing more from the seeds catalog) and it's not clear what tools make. Next time try to do something not ambitious as that. Remember that there are only 48-72 hours, and that sometimdes simple and innovative thing are better! <br/> <br/>2/5 |
| Dec 20 19:13:00 | 6m 00s | Bad Doggie | LOL, what a typical scene. Liked it, your art style is great and fits a lot wih the comic situation. I played it for a while. Good work! <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 20 19:16:00 | 3m 00s | AboveBelow | May the first game I've seen that growing is actually a negative thing. :P Great concept, it's really difficult to control though. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 22 18:28:00 | 47h 12m | Coastal Beacons | Not a bad game, a bit boring after two plays, but if you have more time in the next ludum dare, I thing that with your art style you can make something amazing <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 22 18:37:00 | 9m 00s | PlantBoy | Woah, that's amazing. Porting a game to a Game Boy is really good! Though the gameplay itself it's quite simple and repetitive, what I really vote in this game is that you've a great achievement! <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 24 19:42:00 | 49h 05m | Tama Battle! | Good job with that little online multiplayer! The combats are pvp, or there must be both players connected? <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 24 19:49:00 | 7m 00s | Boo's Adventure | Haha not a bad game, but the controls feels a bit unresponsible (at least for me) and the springs bounce directions are a bit weird. <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 24 19:59:00 | 10m 00s | QUACK! QUACK! Save the duck! | Graphics remembered me to crossy road, LOL. Gameplay is good, but the browser srolls up and down when pressing those two arrow keys. That happens in most web game though (in mines too). Just try to host your game in a site that doesn't need a scroll bar apart that in Gamejolt. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 24 20:08:00 | 9m 00s | SnakeSnakeSnake | Good game, liked that you can climb some platform. The snake seems more a slug than a snake :P, but the graphics are great apart o this. Great work for a two days game. <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 27 20:32:00 | 72h 24m | Growing Ties | Really cute game, combining the aim mechanic with the growing one was a great choice! <br/> <br/>4/5 |
| Dec 28 15:51:00 | 19h 19m | Tile Risers | Really innovative, but it is too random and easy. Good work! <br/> <br/>3/5 |
| Dec 29 12:16:00 | 20h 25m | Novascape | Wow! Great gameboy ROM! The only flaw is the difficult, and that's not exactly a flaw! The best ROM I've seen in this Jam! <br/> <br/>5/5 |
| Dec 31 08:56:00 | 44h 40m | Tamamystery | Awesome game, I got confused sometimes, but it's a great idea. Great use of the theme! <br/> <br/>5/5 |
| Jan 4 15:34:00 | 102h 38m | SlimeCraft | Great game! Sadly, I don't have anyone to play with, but I'll give you a 5/5 just for making a 2-buttons game of that kind! |
| Jan 4 15:43:00 | 9m 00s | Frogtale | Wow, amazing game! Sadly, it's difficult to play with a laptop because it's not posible to move a mouse and press keys simultaenously. But in a computer it should be so enjoyable. :) <br/> <br/>5/5 |